https://www.ory.sh/ logo
Join Slack
Powered by
<@U04UQ68083H> Hello,I want help in this ...
# ory-copilot
s
@chilly-king-10285 Hello,I want help in this please check below for reference ,the problem is when I query for http://somedomain/userinfo the response I'm getting is as follows and there's no email in it 
{
"amr": [
"oidc"
],
"aud": [
"ce7fd896-ee73-4785-b5f1-4aebfdc1a1c9"
],
"auth_time": 1637735144,
"iat": 1618069753,
"iss": "<https://somedomain.com>",
"rat": 1738069749,
"sub": "7e4de2r7-c700-4c7f-be34-3b5d02tay116"
}
Copy code
the custom  identity schema template  is 
{
  "$id": "<https://schemas.ory.sh/presets/kratos/identity.blank.schema.json>",
  "title": "SSO-V10",
  "type": "object",
  "properties": {
    "traits": {
      "type": "object",
      "properties": {
        "email": {
          "title": "Email",
          "type": "string",
          "format": "email",
          "<http://ory.sh/kratos|ory.sh/kratos>": {
            "credentials": {
              "password": {
                "identifier": true
              }
            }
          }
        },
        "first_name": {
          "title": "First Name",
          "type": "string"
        },
        "last_name": {
          "title": "Last Name",
          "type": "string"
        },
        "phone_no": {
          "type": "number",
          "title": "Phone number"
        },
        "country_code": {
          "type": "string",
          "title": "Country Code"
        },
        "company": {
          "type": "object",
          "properties": {
            "company_name": {
              "type": "string",
              "title": "Company Name"
            },
            "company_address": {
              "type": "object",
              "properties": {
                "address_line_1": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "Address Line 1"
                },
                "address_line_2": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "Address Line 2"
                },
                "city": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "City"
                },
                "state": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "State/Province"
                },
                "country": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "Country"
                },
                "zip_code": {
                  "type": "string",
                  "title": "Zip Code"
                }
              },
              "required": []
            }
          },
          "required": []
        }
      },
      "required": [
        "email"
      ],
      "additionalProperties": true
    }
  },
  "$schema": "<http://json-schema.org/draft-07/schema#>"
}
,I'm using SSO provider as google OIDC 
Data Mapping:
local claims = {
email_verified: true,
} + std.extVar('claims');
{
identity: {
traits: {
-- Check if email exists and if it's verified, then map it to 'email'
email: if 'email' in claims && claims.email_verified then claims.email else null,
-- Map other claims as required
first_name: claims.given_name,
last_name: claims.family_name,
},
},
}
scopes:
email ,openid,profile
b
A message from kapa.ai
Based on the information you've provided and the knowledge sources available, it appears that you're experiencing an issue with the userinfo endpoint not returning the email claim. This is likely due to a configuration issue with your OAuth2 and OpenID Connect setup. Let's address this step by step: 1. Scope Configuration: You mentioned that you're using the scopes "email, openid, profile". This is correct and should theoretically return the email claim. However, there might be an issue with how these scopes are being requested or processed. 2. Data Mapping: Your data mapping Jsonnet looks correct. It's set up to map the email if it exists and is verified. 3. Identity Schema: Your identity schema includes an email field, which is good. The main issue seems to be that the email claim is not being included in the userinfo response. Here are a few things to check: 1. Ensure that the OAuth client is configured to allow requesting the 
email
and 
profile
scopes. As mentioned in the [Ory Hydra API discussion](https://github.com/ory/hydra/discussions/3799), this could be a reason for missing claims. 2. Verify that the user agent (your application) is actually requesting these scopes during the authentication process. 3. Make sure the user is consenting to these scopes during the authorization process. 4. Check if the 
email
scope is being properly processed and included in the access token. You can decode the access token to see what claims are included. 5. Ensure that your Ory Hydra configuration is set up to include these claims in the userinfo endpoint response. This might involve checking your Hydra configuration and potentially using [OAuth2 webhooks](https://www.ory.sh/docs/oauth2-oidc/openid-connect-claims-scope-custom) to customize the claims included in your tokens. 6. Verify that the email verification status is being properly carried over from the OIDC provider (Google in this case). There was a known issue with this in the past, as mentioned in a [GitHub issue discussion](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/246). If you've checked all of these and are still having issues, you might want to: 1. Double-check your Ory Hydra and Kratos configurations to ensure they're set up correctly for handling these scopes and claims. 2. Verify that your Google OIDC provider configuration is correct and is set to provide the email claim. 3. Consider using the Ory CLI to inspect your configuration and potentially set additional options for claim handling. If the problem persists after checking these points, you may want to reach out to Ory support or post in the Ory Community Slack for more specific assistance, as the issue might be related to your particular setup or a potential bug in the system.
s
@chilly-king-10285 everything is as expected still the same
@chilly-king-10285 please reply
b
A message from kapa.ai
I apologize, but I need more specific information or a question to provide a helpful response. Is there a particular aspect of your previous issue with the userinfo endpoint and missing email claim that you'd like me to clarify or expand upon? Or do you have a new question related to Ory's products or services? Please provide more details so I can assist you better.
s
the question I asked above ,I have all the setup as above
b
A message from kapa.ai
I apologize for the confusion. If you've checked all the previously mentioned points and everything appears to be configured correctly, yet you're still experiencing the same issue with the missing email claim in the userinfo response, there might be a deeper problem that requires further investigation. Based on the available knowledge sources, I can suggest a few more things to consider: 1. Webhook Configuration: According to the [Ory Network GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206), there was a known bug where the email claim was missing from the ID token and userinfo response when consent was remembered. To address this, you might want to check if you have a webhook configured for token issuance. If you do, make sure it's properly set up to include the email claim. 2. Consent Remember: If you're using the "Remember my decision" feature in the consent flow, this could potentially be causing the issue. Try performing the OAuth2 flow without remembering the consent and see if the email claim appears. 3. ID Token vs Userinfo: Check if the email claim is present in the ID Token even if it's missing from the userinfo endpoint. This could help isolate where the problem is occurring. 4. Custom Claims: As mentioned in the [Ory documentation on userinfo endpoint](https://www.ory.sh/docs/oauth2-oidc/userinfo-oidc), you can add custom claims to the userinfo response. You might want to try this approach to explicitly include the email claim:
Copy code
javascript
   export async function acceptConsent(consentChallenge: string) {
     const { data } = await ory.getOAuth2ConsentRequest({ consentChallenge })
     
     return await ory
       .acceptOAuth2ConsentRequest({
         consentChallenge: consentChallenge,
         acceptOAuth2ConsentRequest: {
           session: {
             id_token: {
               email: "<mailto:user@example.com|user@example.com>", // Replace with actual email
             },
           },
         },
       })
       .then(({ data }) => data)
   }
5. Google OIDC Provider Specifics: There's a specific issue mentioned in the [Ory Network GitHub](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/242) about Google's OIDC provider. Google doesn't support the "offline_access" scope directly. Instead, it uses the parameter 
access_type=offline
. Make sure your configuration for the Google provider is set up correctly:
Copy code
yaml
   oidc:
     config:
       providers:
       - client_id: xxxx
         client_secret: xxx
         id: google
         label: Google
         mapper_url: xxx
         provider: google
         scope:
         - email
         - profile
         - <https://www.googleapis.com/auth/gmail.compose>
         - <https://www.googleapis.com/auth/gmail.readonly>
And ensure that the 
access_type=offline
is being added to the auth URL when necessary.
I apologize for the confusion. If you've checked all the previously mentioned points and everything appears to be configured correctly, yet you're still experiencing the same issue with the missing email claim in the userinfo response, there might be a deeper problem that requires further investigation. Based on the available knowledge sources, I can suggest a few more things to consider: 1. Webhook Configuration: According to the [Ory Network GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206), there was a known bug where the email claim was missing from the ID token and userinfo response when consent was remembered. To address this, you might want to check if you have a webhook configured for token issuance. If you do, make sure it's properly set up to include the email claim. 2. Consent Remember: If you're using the "Remember my decision" feature in the consent flow, this could potentially be causing the issue. Try performing the OAuth2 flow without remembering the consent and see if the email claim appears. 3. ID Token vs Userinfo: Check if the email claim is present in the ID Token even if it's missing from the userinfo endpoint. This could help isolate where the problem is occurring. 4. Custom Claims: As mentioned in the [Ory documentation on userinfo endpoint](https://www.ory.sh/docs/oauth2-oidc/userinfo-oidc), you can add custom claims to the userinfo response. You might want to try this approach to explicitly include the email claim:
Copy code
javascript    export async function acceptConsent(consentChallenge: string) {      const { data } = await ory.getOAuth2ConsentRequest({ consentChallenge })            return await ory        .acceptOAuth2ConsentRequest({          consentChallenge: consentChallenge,          acceptOAuth2ConsentRequest: {            session: {              id_token: {                email: "<mailto:user@example.com|user@example.com>", // Replace with actual email              },            },          },        })        .then(({ data }) => data)    }
5. Google OIDC Provider Specifics: There's a specific issue mentioned in the [Ory Network GitHub](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/242) about Google's OIDC provider. Google doesn't support the "offline_access" scope directly. Instead, it uses the parameter 
access_type=offline
. Make sure your configuration for the Google provider is set up correctly:
Copy code
yaml    oidc:      config:        providers:        - client_id: xxxx          client_secret: xxx          id: google          label: Google          mapper_url: xxx          provider: google          scope:          - email          - profile          - <https://www.googleapis.com/auth/gmail.compose>          - <https://www.googleapis.com/auth/gmail.readonly>
And ensure that the 
access_type=offline
is being added to the auth URL when necessary. If after checking these additional points you're still experiencing the same issue, I would strongly recommend reaching out to Ory support directly or posting in the Ory Community Slack. The problem might be specific to your environment or could potentially be a bug that needs to be addressed by the Ory team.
s
@chilly-king-10285 still no luck I unchecked remeber my decission
b
A message from kapa.ai
I understand your frustration. Even after unchecking "Remember my decision," you're still not seeing the email claim in the userinfo response. This persistent issue suggests that there might be a deeper configuration problem or possibly a bug in the system. Based on the available knowledge sources, here are a few more specific things you can try: 1. Check the ID Token: As mentioned in the [Ory Network GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206), there was a bug where the email claim was missing from both the ID token and the userinfo response. Try decoding your ID token to see if the email claim is present there. If it's in the ID token but not in the userinfo response, this could help isolate the problem. 2. Verify Email Scope Processing: Make sure that the 
email
scope is being properly processed. As mentioned in the [Ory documentation on customizing OpenID Connect scopes and claims](https://www.ory.sh/docs/oauth2-oidc/openid-connect-claims-scope-custom), the system uses the verifiable addresses of a user for the 
email
scope. Ensure that your user has a verified email address in their Ory Identities profile. 3. Check Verifiable Addresses: In your Ory Identities configuration, make sure that the user's email is listed under verifiable addresses and is marked as verified. 4. Implement a Custom Consent Endpoint: As suggested in a [GitHub comment](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/267#issuecomment-1465958644), you might want to consider implementing a custom consent endpoint. This would give you full control over what data goes into your tokens and the userinfo response. 5. Use OAuth2 Webhooks: As mentioned in the [Ory documentation](https://www.ory.sh/docs/oauth2-oidc/openid-connect-claims-scope-custom), you can use OAuth2 webhooks to add custom claims to your tokens for different OAuth flows. This might be a way to ensure the email claim is included. If none of these solutions work, it's possible that you're encountering a bug or a configuration issue that's specific to your setup. In this case, I strongly recommend reaching out to Ory support directly with detailed information about your setup, including: - Your complete OAuth2 and OpenID Connect configuration - The exact flow you're using to authenticate - The full response you're getting from the userinfo endpoint - Any error messages or logs you're seeing They will be able to provide more specific assistance based on your exact configuration and environment.
s
@chilly-king-10285 I debuged the id token but there's no email in it
b
A message from kapa.ai
Thank you for providing that additional information. The fact that the email claim is missing from both the userinfo endpoint and the ID token suggests a more fundamental issue with how the claims are being processed or included during the authentication flow. Based on the available knowledge sources, here are some potential reasons and steps to investigate: 1. Consent and Scope Issues: As mentioned in the [Ory Network GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206), there was a known issue where email claims were missing when consent was remembered. Even though you've unchecked "Remember my decision," it's worth double-checking that the 
email
scope is being properly requested and consented to during the authentication process. 2. Data Mapping: Review your data mapping configuration. According to your previous message, you're using a Jsonnet snippet for mapping. Ensure that this mapping is correctly implemented and that it's being applied during the authentication process. You might want to log the claims received from the Google OIDC provider to ensure the email is being passed correctly. 3. Identity Schema: Your identity schema includes an email field, which is correct. However, make sure that the email is actually being populated in the identity when it's created or updated through the OIDC flow. 4. OAuth2 Token Hook: As described in a [GitHub issue about email claims](https://github.com/ory/hydra/issues/3879), you might want to implement an OAuth2 token hook. This hook can be used to add or modify claims in the tokens. Here's an example of how you might set this up:
Copy code
ory patch oauth2-config --project PROJECT --workspace WORKSPACE \    --add '/oauth2/token_hook/url="<https://TUNNEL/claims>"' \    --add '/oauth2/token_hook/auth/type="api_key"' \    --add '/oauth2/token_hook/auth/config/in="header"' \    --add '/oauth2/token_hook/auth/config/name="X-API-Key"' \    --add '/oauth2/token_hook/auth/config/value="SOME_API_KEY"' \    --format yaml
Then, in your webhook handler, you can explicitly add the email claim to the token. 5. Google OIDC Provider Configuration: Ensure that your Google OIDC provider is correctly configured to provide the email claim. Check the scopes you're requesting and make sure they include 
email
. 6. Debugging: Enable debug logging in your Ory setup to get more detailed information about the authentication process. This might help identify where the email claim is being lost or not included. If after checking these points you're still not seeing the email claim in either the ID token or the userinfo endpoint, it's likely that you're encountering a bug or a configuration issue specific to your setup. In this case, I strongly recommend reaching out to Ory support directly with detailed logs and configuration information. They will be able to provide more specific assistance based on your exact setup and environment.
s
@chilly-king-10285 how to do debug logging i ory setup
b
A message from kapa.ai
To enable debug logging in your Ory setup, you can adjust the log level configuration. Here's how you can do it: 1. For Ory Kratos, Hydra, and other Ory services, you can set the log level using environment variables or configuration files. According to the [Ory documentation on logging](https://www.ory.sh/docs/self-hosted/operations/logging), you can set the log level as follows: Using environment variables:
Copy code
export LOG_LEVEL=debug
Or in your configuration file (e.g., 
kratos.yml
or 
hydra.yml
):
Copy code
yaml    log:      level: debug      format: json
2. The 
debug
log level provides very verbose logging. If you need even more detailed information, you can use the 
trace
level, which includes call traces of errors and log calls. 3. You can also adjust the log format. The 
format
configuration key supports 
text
and 
json
. JSON format can be easier to parse programmatically:
Copy code
yaml    log:      level: debug      format: json
4. Be cautious with sensitive data. There's a configuration option 
leak_sensitive_values
which should typically be set to `false`:
Copy code
yaml    log:      level: debug      format: json      leak_sensitive_values: false
5. Log output is sent to stdout/stderr by default. You can redirect this to a file using bash pipes if needed:
Copy code
hydra serve all >log.txt 2>&1
Remember, debug logging can generate a large volume of logs, so it's recommended to use it judiciously and only when needed for troubleshooting. For more detailed information on Ory logging configuration, you can refer to the [Ory documentation on logs and audit trails](https://www.ory.sh/docs/self-hosted/operations/logging).
s
@chilly-king-10285 it's super crazy is ory gong to do something on it or not
b
A message from kapa.ai
I apologize, but I'm not entirely sure what you mean by "cary" in this context. However, I can address your concern about whether Ory is going to do something about the issue you're experiencing with missing email claims in the ID token and userinfo endpoint. Based on the available knowledge sources, Ory is aware of issues related to missing claims and is actively working on improvements. Here are a few relevant points: 1. Known Issues: As mentioned in the [Ory Network GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206), there have been known issues with missing email claims in ID tokens and userinfo responses. Ory has acknowledged these issues and has been working on fixes. 2. Ongoing Improvements: Ory is continuously improving their products. For example, they have implemented some minimal mapping that works out of the box for core OIDC scopes, as mentioned in a [comment on a GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/261#issuecomment-1485500084). 3. Future Plans: There are discussions about implementing more flexible ways to customize session data and claims. As noted in a [comment on another GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/323#issuecomment-1485501329), Ory has an item on their backlog to allow customizing session data using JsonNet, which would receive the request context and identity information. 4. Community Feedback: Ory takes user feedback seriously. They often incorporate user suggestions and bug reports into their development process. While I can't provide a specific timeline for when your particular issue will be resolved, it's clear that Ory is actively working on improving their identity and access management solutions, including addressing issues related to claims in tokens and responses. In the meantime, if you're experiencing critical issues, I would recommend reaching out to Ory support directly or posting in the Ory Community Slack. They may be able to provide you with more specific information about plans to address your particular concern or offer a workaround tailored to your use case.
A message from kapa.ai
I understand your frustration with the situation. Based on the information available in the knowledge sources, I can provide some insight into Ory's approach to addressing issues like the one you're experiencing: 1. Acknowledgment of Issues: Ory is aware of problems related to missing claims in ID tokens and userinfo responses. This is evidenced by discussions in various GitHub issues, such as [this one about email claims](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/206). 2. Ongoing Improvements: Ory is actively working on enhancing their products. For instance, they've implemented some basic mapping for core OIDC scopes, as mentioned in a [comment on a GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/261#issuecomment-1485500084). 3. Future Plans: Ory has plans to implement more flexible ways to customize session data and claims. A [comment on a GitHub issue](https://github.com/ory/network/issues/323#issuecomment-1485501329) mentions that they have an item on their backlog to allow customizing session data using JsonNet. 4. Community Engagement: Ory values user feedback and often incorporates it into their development process. While I can't provide a specific timeline for when your particular issue will be resolved, it's clear that Ory is actively working on improving their identity and access management solutions. Given the complexity and critical nature of your issue, I strongly recommend reaching out to Ory support directly or posting in the Ory Community Slack. They can provide you with more specific information about plans to address your particular concern or offer a tailored workaround for your use case. Remember, identity and access management systems are complex, and resolving issues while maintaining security and compatibility can take time. Ory seems committed to improving their products, but the process may not always be as fast as users hope.
Open in Slack
PreviousNext
Powered by